Home » Grading the Biggest Moves of the MLB Offseason
mlb offseason

Grading the Biggest Moves of the MLB Offseason

The MLB offseason is beginning to heat up after a slow start, and we’re here to break down the biggest deals so far. From free agent contracts to blockbuster trades, here are some first reactions to the deals that have happened thus far.

 

RHP Davis Martin & RHP Luis Castillo Traded to the Rockies

Rockies Grade: B (received RHP Martin and RHP Castillo)

Colorado desperately needed starting pitching, and they acquired two proven arms. Both pitchers struggled down the stretch in 2026, but at their peak they are solid starters.

White Sox Grade: D (received prospects LHP Sean Sullivan and C Douglas Veliz)

The White Sox biggest weakness in the postseason this year was starting pitching, and they solve that by trading two away? Both struggled in 2026, but Martin at least had some upside. The prospect return is underwhelming for two major league pitchers.

 

LHP Sonny Gray Signed by the Twins (2yr, $55m)

Grade: A

Minnesota brings back a player they are familiar with. Gray, who had a fantastic season in 2026, will look to keep that train rolling with his new team. The Twins will now have a formidable starting rotation if they stay healthy.

 

3B Maikel Garcia Traded to the Mariners

Mariners Grade: B+ (received 3B Garcia, RHP James McArthur, and prospect RHP L.P. Langevin)

Seattle needed help on the left side of the infield badly. Their third baseman collectively had the worst bWAR of any 3B unit in baseball in 2026. The only thing holding this back from being an A is that Garcia has had some health issues.

Royals Grade: B (RHP Bryce Miller, LHP José A. Ferrer, and RHP Logan Evans)

The Royals pitching staff struggled mightily in 2026, and this is a shot at solidifying that unit. All three pitchers they received are big league-caliber, and Miller has ace potential. Giving up Garcia was a big swing. Hopefully for KC, it pays off.

 

1B Jake Bauers Signed by the Red Sox (4yr, $58m)

Grade: C

I appreciate the urgency by the Red Sox in getting one of the premier bats on the market. Bauers showed with Milwaukee that he can have a huge impact on a game. The need for Boston isn’t at first base, though. Willson Contreras played great last year. The holes on the roster are elsewhere.

 

RHP Evan Phillips Signed by the Braves (3yr, $35m)

Grade: B-

Once again, a move that is a bit of a head-scratcher when you consider that Atlanta had one of the best bullpens in baseball last year. Their issues mostly came down to infield production. That said, you can never have too many good bullpen arms.

 

RHP Emilio Pagan Signed by the Tigers (1yr, $11.5m)

Grade: A

Pagan is a solid closer and was good for the Reds when he was healthy during the 2026 season. The Tigers were led in saves by veteran Kenley Jansen, who is now a free agent. Signing Pagan gets them a reliable arm to close out games.

 

RHP Dustin May Signed by the White Sox (3yr, 52.5m)

Grade: D

This feels like a desperation signing from the White Sox. They needed starting pitching, even before the trade with the Rockies, but this is a lot of money to throw at a guy who had a 4.70 ERA in 2026. May couldn’t find any consistency with St. Louis or Milwaukee; perhaps he can find it in Chicago.

 

INF Royce Lewis Traded to the Dodgers

Twins Grade: B (receive RHP Bobby Miller and prospect C Francisco Espinoza)

The Twins once again went on the hunt for young, controllable starting pitching. They got Miller, who has a great fastball and is only 27 years old. They sold high on Lewis, who finally had a healthy season, but had run his course in Minnesota.

Dodgers Grade: A (receive INF Royce Lewis)

Another trade for Los Angeles where they use their considerable resources to take a flyer on a player. It has worked before, and it may very well work again. Lewis has been hampered by injuries throughout his career, but has number-one draft pick talent and pedigree.

 

Follow The Game Haus on Google

Add The Game Haus as a Preferred Source to see more of our gaming, esports, and sports coverage in Google Search.

 

Leave A Reply

* required

The Game Haus covers gaming, esports and sports through focused ecosystems, guides, rankings, analysis and videos.





Explore:
Pokemon | Pokemon Champions | NFL | NFL Draft | Fantasy Football | College Football | Deadlock
Watch:
Pokemon Haus | Draft Haus | Dead Unlocked | The Game Haus
Follow:
TGH Sports on Twitter/X | TGH Esports on Twitter/X | Sports Facebook | Esports Facebook



Players must be 21 years of age or older or reach the minimum age for gambling in their respective state and located in jurisdictions where online gambling is legal. Please play responsibly. Bet with your head, not over it. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, and wants help, call or visit: (a) the Council on Compulsive Gambling of New Jersey at 1-800-Gambler or www.800gambler.org; or (b) Gamblers Anonymous at 855-2-CALL-GA or www.gamblersanonymous.org.

×
Your Promo Code:
The bonus offer of was already opened in an additional window. If not, you can open it also by clicking the following link:
Play now